As the rising, inclusive, more equal opportunity and sustaining outcome Stakeholder Economy takes shape, buttressed by non-purpose washing ESGs & SDGs practiced for real by social enterprises, impact investors, philanthropy, and government innovators; socioeconomic cracks are beginning to appear which, if unresolved, can widen problems instead of expanding solutions. A rapidly appealing, immediate postpandemic enterprise conversion imperative risks stumbling into a contentious pit of unfair tax structure differences, unaligned vocabulary, uncorrected and outdated misperceptions and in some cases, intentional misinformation on the part of one about the other.
This creeping multi-dimensional imbalance is further exacerbated by the rising origin and outcome differences between potential worker and existing employee owners. The former exceeds the latter in terms of diversity and population acceleration as gig economy “work more for less” and egregious worker misclassification practices advanced by grifter corporations deliberately confuse consumer choice with workplace justice.
The “Great Resignation” showcases how “moral injury” directly linked to exploitative and extractive workplace culture results in millions of American workers choosing to reject continued workplace trauma laid even more bare during a pandemic that out mutates tried and found wanting structural solutions to date. The opportunity before us is to reclaim, convene, and empower Big Tent worker ownership models and encourage emerging hybrid spin-offs based on purpose driven values, mission impacts and performance metrics.
1worker1vote and ASBN (https://www.asbnetwork.org/), through our ever-evolving “Ownership4All” campaign believe that we have a once in a generation opportunity to move the needle on seeding civil society enriching worker and employee ownership. This is especially relevant following the 2020-2021 pandemic’s economic ravages exposing mortality-enhancing inequalities underlining the mandate to go much farther than the 2018 passage of the bipartisan Main Street Employee Ownership Act that targeted, but has not yet succeeded in opening up the US SBA to hybrid ownership models for greater SBA loan access. The intended inclusion of the co-op/employee ownership lending fund (SEC. 100504. FUNDING FOR COOPERATIVES – “This section provides $100 million to fund a pilot program for eligible cooperatives and employee-owned businesses to receive SBA loan products without the requirement of a personal or entity guarantee in reconciliation”), a priority for Leader Schumer, Chairman Cardin and Chairwoman Velazquez, represents a sine qua non advancement in this direction towards full worker ownership structural equality.
ASBN/1worker1vote have been interfacing with the White House Task Force on Worker Empowerment since its inception and the SBA pilot program is clearly a major result to support and communicate as broadly and consistently as possible. The next step in this process is to deliver on tax parity. There are several models of worker ownership, and the resulting inequalities and regulatory confusion contribute to the fragmentation and disparities of current tax law. Tax laws treat cooperatives differently than ESOPs, and S Corp ESOPs are treated differently than C Corp ESOPs. Investors get to choose the tax structure best for them, usually ESOPs, but this is not necessarily the best approach for workers especially those who are unionized, gig economy structured and socioeconomically marginalized.
U.S. tax law must be changed to make tax treatment more uniform for all worker ownership models so hosting communities and their emerging worker-owners can choose the model and approach best culturally suited for them instead of having to conform to a structure imposed by any outgoing investor-owner. Leaving the plantation means leaving the plantation. Tax parity leads to more inclusive, fair, and integrated workplace and civic culture as well as a more fulfilled, empowered and democratically enabled workforce.
Empowering Stakeholder Economy Formulas demanding the immediate urgency of now:
- Collective Guaranty + Collective Bargaining Agreement = a business model that can respond to all four ESG capital sources: Societal, Human, Climate & Financial.
- Collective Guaranty (SBA reconciliation language) + CEA + tax parity = brave new world for worker ownership, equity & structural democratic governance seeding freedom of choice.
To reunite the country and heal the inequities of our COVID-recovering economy, metrics show that broad based, worker ownership social enterprises and ecosystems through shared high road principles and practices are more stable, inclusive, equitable, democratic, and competitive with fewer job losses, especially during downturns. Research proves that combining an equity stake with participatory ownership culture (essentially the definition of a worker cooperative) creates better businesses. The basic democratic principle valued in nation-states and shared-ownership models is one-person-one-vote. An equity share is the right to vote and provides the basis for a new power-paradigm-changing culture that builds community wealth and stability, civic-solidarity, self-reliance, and more secure retirements.
Today, “flattening the curves” means reconciliation not just of opposites but of those who should be collaborating instead of falling into a classical, unproductive “us-versus-them” traps sapping momentum, inspiration, outcomes and sacred time. All too often, demeaning one structure to advance the other results in a circular firing squad liquidating and re-marginalizing millions of workers voting with their feet for a better social and civic compact.
The “Ownership4All” campaign holds that “building it back better” must include “fairer” to guarantee aspiring worker and employee owners receive transparently “best” practices. Learning the hard way that everything is downstream from culture, this campaign allows for hosting neighborhoods, barrios, boroughs and their emerging local worker-owner stakeholders shouldering these new social enterprises to have the freedom to choose the model and approach best culturally suited for them. Increasingly, ESG/SDG impact investor practitioners are learning that human, social and natural capitol can make or break financial capital starting with shared culture driving shared profitable returns on balance sheets uplifting those who do the work, their families, and communities.
The ASBN/1worker1vote “Ownership4All” campaign pursues four foundational policy goals and is open to others representing similar values and mission purpose:
- Tax Policy parity with ESOPs for hybrid and diverse ownership models including worker and union cooperatives, as well as other emerging, hybrid shared ownership structures (HSOS)in federal laws.
- There are several models of worker ownership, and this variety contributes to the fragmentation of the law. Tax laws treat cooperatives differently than ESOPs, and S Corp ESOPs are treated differently than C Corp ESOPs.
- Such laws must be changed to make tax treatment more uniform for all worker ownership models so hosting communities and their emerging worker-owners can choose the model and approach best for them. Tax parity leads to more inclusive, fair and integrated civic culture
- A first step would be to implement a leveled tax policy playing field offering an S-Corp ESOPlike corporate income tax exemption, and the ability to deduct both interest and principal on a worker cooperative loan. This way, ESOP/employee ownership successes in wealth creation can be extended to worker coops, union-coops, and other hybrid worker ownership structures. Hybrid worker ownership structures will become the norm, not the exception, as this practice community expands.
- At a minimum, “enlightened” or “democratic” ESOPs must show a clear differentiation between retirement plan and ownership plan incentives and how to reach higher ground on both benefits workers to pursue and reflect these structural goals:
- single class stock for all worker owners (engenders solidarity and purpose-driven culture),
- independently verified fair and transparent market valuations (avoids criminality)
- investors who cash out only based on company performance over time (shared risks/shared rewards),
- high impact democratic workplace participation (worker owners exhibit higher business financial literacy),
- a workforce that ends up owning the majority of company stock (how the Stakeholder Economy and a renewing, inclusive “solidarity dividend” civic society rise),
- and anti-demutualization and outsourcing/offshoring provisions so that the jobs and the enterprises stay local (more important in a pandemic-recovering economy than ever before since the Great Depression).
- Enabling paths to transition: The transition to worker ownership requires technical help in the form of business and market assessments, legal assistance in structuring the transition, and training employee purchasers to run the business.
- On a regional basis, this can be integrated into shared services cooperatives within structures of existing organizations already working closely with ASBN and 1worker1vote (e.g., The Vermont Employee Ownership Center, the Rocky Mountain Employee Ownership Center, The ONE movement in Oregon, The Cooperative Catalyst movement in New Mexico, and The Ohio Employee Ownership Center, Coop Cincy and Coop Dayton – now part of a statewide organization, OWON – https://www.oeockent.org/the-ohio-worker-ownership-network ).
- Access to capital: Many traditional banks don’t know enough about worker-owned businesses to feel comfortable lending to them. Legislation can create ways to raise funds, either through changes to tax law or an increase in government loans. ASBC member, the South Carolina Small Business Chamber of Commerce led by ASBN board member, Frank Knapp, has launched the “Reform the SBA” campaign – https://scsbc.org/sc-group-calling-for-changes-to-the-sba/
- Equalize the EB5 immigrant investor visa $500,000 benefit to allow worker and union coops and other hybrid shared ownership structures (HSOS) to provide equal visa access to documented and undocumented union coop worker owners by similarly validating the ownership equity value in their enterprises as “skin in the game” entrepreneurial capital, similar to any other investor.
To conclude, the 1worker1vote/ASBN “Ownership4All” campaign confronts yesterday’s zero-sum, socioeconomic class-burdened mindset and seizes the opportunity to build a more equitable and just economy by advancing deepened and broadened worker and employee ownership practices and practitioners. As 1worker1vote states and examples like Black LA’s DCR campaign prove, “although it is well known that ‘nothing about us, without us, is for us’, also the reverse is true, that ‘everything cooperatively about us, with us, is for all of us’. Heather McGhee in “Rise of the Rest of Us” calls this the ‘Solidarity Dividend’ which when put into motion is highly short-mid-long-term human, social and financial capital profitable.” “Ownership4All” serves as the “secular civic inclusive prosperity & opportunity commons” restitching, outreaching to and reuniting all of the country starting in its most damaged places.